Jay Leno’s Conservatorship Case: Why Incapacity Planning Matters in Alabama & Florida
- Colin McMichen
- Jan 28
- 6 min read
Updated: Jan 28
Many Families Assume Love Is Enough
Many people believe that if something happens to them, their spouse will automatically be able to step in and handle everything.
Pay the bills. Manage investments. Make medical decisions.
It feels logical. It feels fair.
But Jay Leno’s experience shows that, legally, this is not always true.
In 2024, Jay Leno — beloved comedian and former host of The Tonight Show — filed court paperwork seeking a conservatorship over his wife, Mavis Leno’s estate after her dementia progressed to the point that she could no longer manage her financial and legal affairs. A California court granted the petition, appointing him as conservator.
What many people do not realize is that Jay Leno also asked the court to approve a long-term plan so that Mavis would continue receiving care if he were to pass away before her. Even with decades of marriage and no family dispute, court involvement was still required.
For families in Alabama and Florida, this case sends a clear message. Without proper incapacity planning, even spouses may need court approval to care for each other.
When Incapacity Strikes Without Planning
When someone becomes incapacitated without legal documents in place, families often discover they have no automatic authority to step in.
Banks may refuse access. Doctors may hesitate to share information. Financial institutions may freeze accounts.
At that point, loved ones are left with one primary option: petition the court for guardianship or conservatorship.
That process can mean:
Public court filings
Medical evaluations
Hearings and judicial oversight
Ongoing reporting requirements
Significant time and expense
Even when everyone agrees on what should happen.
What Jay Leno’s Case Really Teaches
Jay Leno’s case did not happen because he failed to care for his wife.
It happened because the right legal authority had not been established before incapacity occurred.
The law requires written documentation — not good intentions — to give someone authority to act.
This is exactly why incapacity planning exists.
The Tools That Keep Families Out of Court
Proper incapacity planning allows you to choose who will make decisions for you if you cannot.
Two of the most important tools are a durable power of attorney and a living will / health care surrogate.
Durable Power of Attorney
A durable power of attorney authorizes someone to handle financial and legal matters if you become incapacitated.
In Alabama, powers of attorney executed after January 1, 2012, are presumed to be durable and continue to be effective even if the person later becomes incapacitated, unless the document expressly states otherwise (Ala. Code § 26-1A-104).
In Florida, a durable power of attorney remains effective after incapacity when it includes language stating that it is not terminated by the principal’s subsequent incapacity (Fla. Stat. § 709.2104).
A durable power of attorney is one of the main ways to avoid conservatorship in Alabama and guardianship in Florida. Without this document, families often must ask a judge for permission to act.
Living Will & Health Care Surrogate
Both Alabama and Florida law allow you to decide two very important things in advance:
What medical care you want if you are seriously ill and cannot speak for yourself, and
Who you trust to make medical decisions on your behalf.
Putting these wishes in writing can spare your family from stress, confusion, and disagreements during an already difficult time.
In Alabama, you can sign an Advance Directive for Health Care (Ala. Code § 22-8A-4). This document may include a living will, which lets you state your wishes about life-sustaining treatment, and a health care proxy designation, which names the person you want making medical decisions if you cannot communicate.
In Florida, you can sign a living will and name a health care surrogate under Chapter 765 of the Florida Statutes. These documents let you explain the type of care you would want in situations like terminal illness or permanent unconsciousness, and choose someone you trust to speak for you if you are unable to do so.
An advance directive or health care surrogate designation gives you control over your medical care — and gives your loved ones clear guidance. Without these documents, doctors may have to rely on default rules or family members may need to go to court before decisions can be made.
What Happens Without Planning in Alabama
Alabama law allows probate courts to appoint a guardian or conservator when a person is unable to manage their personal or financial affairs. A guardian is given authority to make medical decisions and a conservator is given authority to manage financial affairs for the incapacitated individual.
This often requires:
Medical evidence
Court hearings
Continued court oversight
Once again, decisions shift from the family to the court.
What Happens Without Planning in Florida
If valid incapacity planning documents are not in place, Florida law allows courts to appoint a guardian for an incapacitated person. This individual may make financial and medical decisions for the incapacitated person.
Guardianship cases involve:
A court determination of incapacity
Appointment of a guardian
Ongoing court supervision
These proceedings are public and can be emotionally and financially draining.
Nominating Guardians and Conservators in Advance
One of the most powerful steps you can take in incapacity planning is to nominate who you want to act for you if you can no longer make decisions yourself.
Alabama: Nominate in Your Power of Attorney
In Alabama, when you sign your power of attorney, you can go a step further than just naming someone to act on your behalf. You can include language that nominates your preferred guardian and conservator should a court ever need to appoint one. This is particularly important because, without this nomination, a judge may appoint someone you would not choose.
By including a nomination clause in your power of attorney, you tell the court who you trust most to make financial, legal, and personal decisions if you become incapacitated. Even if your agent under the power of attorney is unable or unwilling to serve, your nomination guides the court’s decision, making it more likely that the person you want will be appointed.
This nomination gives you greater control over your future planning and helps your family avoid disputes and uncertainty.
Florida: Nominate a Guardian in a Declaration Naming a Preneed Guardian
In Florida, you can achieve a similar goal through a separate document called a Declaration Naming Preneed Guardian. Under Florida Statutes § 744.3045, a competent adult can sign this declaration to express their preference for who should be appointed as their guardian in the event they become incapacitated and a guardianship is necessary.
This Florida declaration helps a judge understand who you want as your guardian — rather than leaving that choice up to the court or family members who may disagree.
Why This Matters
By nominating your guardian (and, in Alabama, your conservator) ahead of time:
You reduce the chance of a court appointing someone you would not have chosen.
You give clear guidance to the court and your loved ones.
You add another layer of protection and peace of mind to your incapacity plan.
These nominations are simple to include but very powerful in outcome — and they complement documents like durable powers of attorney and advance directives to create a complete incapacity planning strategy.
The Bigger Picture
Jay Leno went to court to protect his wife.
Most families would rather never step inside a courtroom at all.
With proper incapacity planning in Alabama and Florida, families can:
Keep private matters private
Avoid guardianship and conservatorship
Choose decision-makers in advance
Ensure continuity of care
Reduce stress and uncertainty
Incapacity planning is not about expecting the worst.
It is about protecting the people you love.
Your Next Step
If you or your spouse become incapacitated tomorrow:
Who will manage your finances?
Who will make medical decisions?
Will your family need court approval to help you?
If you are unsure, it may be time to review, or create, your durable powers of attorney, advance directives, living wills, and overall incapacity plan.
A simple conversation today can prevent a crisis tomorrow.
About the Author
Colin McMichen is an experienced attorney and the founder of Provident Law / Estate Planning LLC, a Birmingham, Alabama-based firm. With a focus on estate planning and probate law, Colin is dedicated to helping individuals and families in Alabama and Florida navigate complex legal matters with confidence.
Comments